My joy for today is defending the choices of American mothers.
A few days ago, Hilary Rosen, speaking in support of the Democratic Party, said that Ann Romney could not understand the economic problems of women because she, as a stay home mother, had “never worked a day in her life.” In the time since, the Obama campaign has emphatically distanced themselves from Ms. Rosen, the President and the First Lady issued statements in support of stay at home mothers and the personal choices of women, and Ms. Rosen publicly apologized and cancelled a scheduled television appearance.
This morning, Mara Liasson, NPR’s National Political Correspondent, was discussing the recent media frenzy over Hilary Rosen’s comment. Ms. Liasson summarized events of the past few days and then was attempting to segue into talking about the differences in female voter support for each candidate. In doing so, she continued the demeaning and belittling conversation on stay at home mothers. She began the next part of her commentary with this quote:
“His [Mitt Romney’s] problem isn’t with stay at home moms, it’s with educated women.”
Stay at home moms are not or cannot also be educated? Ms. Liasson and NPR, is this your official stance on my demographic?
I attempted to find the transcript and audio file of this morning’s broadcast. The file that is available for the 8 am show does not contain the quote that I have discussed. Ironically, the audio file and transcript are simply not the same as the one we heard in the car this morning. I do not claim to understand the intricacies of radio broadcasting and realize that there may have been many versions of the broadcast that we heard. However, the quote by Ms. Liasson was certainly part of at least one version of today’s program, and many comments on NPR’s website show that we are not the only listeners who caught this outrageous comment. If Hilary Rosen owed women an apology, it seems only fair that Ms. Liasson and NPR do the same. In the spirit of honest journalism, why not admit your mistake and apologize to your faithful listeners? Do you assume that stay at home mothers are so uneducated that they were not even listening and therefore are not even owed a response? Please do not continue to belittle us with your silence.
The many ways in which this statement by NPR is incredibly insulting seem almost too obvious to list. But for the sake of my daughters, and in hopes that they will someday read this and know that their mother was in fact, both choosing to be at home with them, and educated, please indulge me while I expound this topic.
Hilary Rosen began this onslaught against stay at home mothers by stating that we do not work. She was obviously referring to gainful employment, we are not paid for our profession, and so we understand her point, albeit insulting and grossly misstated. Mara Liasson basically stated that stay at home mothers, as a group, cannot also be educated women. I find Ms. Liasson’s comment even more insulting than Ms. Rosen’s because it is revealing her own, and possibly the nation’s or large parts of society’s, deeply held, demeaning views on my chosen profession.
Dear National Public Radio, Ms. Liasson, and Society as a whole:
Please stop assuming and propagating the erroneous and discriminatory notion that I am not educated simply because I am a woman and I choose to be at home with my children. A degree is not required to raise my children at home. But I have one. In fact, I have more than one. I choose to spend a large part of my day teaching my daughter to read and reviewing sentence diagramming with my son, but that does not mean that I could not also discuss the current political climate or the nuclear situation in North Korea. I choose to limit myself and my career because I believe it is best for my family that I be at home with my children. This is not sad. This is not anti-feminist. This is my choice as an educated American woman.
Enjoy your joys for today.
My sister kicks butt! Ask world magazine ;)
I totally agree with this statement, and I can only hope to find as intelligent, wise, and passionate of a spouse, as I have for a sister (and the many other strong ladies in our family). I couldn’t be more proud of you! It takes real bravery and selflessness to sacrifice the accolades of a business career in order to serve her own family and dependent children.
Thanks Spence! I will have to live vicariously through my brother’s amazing film career. ;-)
I arrived here through the NPR/Weekend Edition Sunday comments link you left. Thank you for a) validating what I heard, and b) validating what, I, too, think about educated stay-at-home mothers and women in general. Peace out.
I was also very glad to see that others had commented on this disparity between what we heard and what NPR has recorded as the official transcript. Thank you so much for your comment and for the support.
I am so proud of you for speaking up on this topic. I have always felt it is such an honor to be able to stay at home with our children. I believe this is so important and actually feel sorry for women who are not able to, if they so desire. I do respect women who want to work outside the home for their own ‘important reasons’, but I am so thankful I was able to be a stay at home Mom. And we have three beautiful, wonderful, educated, amazing children to show for it! I am so proud of my two daughters for desiring to be educated, loving stay-at-home moms, and that my son would be happy for his yet to meet, future wife to be in this beautiful position. I am also very thankful that my wonderful husband also shared this desire!
Thanks Mom! You were my first and best example. Love you!
I tell people all the time that Amber has the harder job, and one that I could never do. I think NPR and Mara Liasson owe two appologies: (1) For the remarks made by Mara Liasson and (2) For editing the audio file and transcript to remove the aired version of the statement.
I totally agree about NPR. If only people would notice! And I am thankful that you are supportive of my career choices.
You tell ’em Amber! I couldn’t agree with you more and, speaking from experience, I totally agree with Chad’s comments. While living in the business world can be extremely stressful and challenging, successfully raising children and managing the home scene would be more demanding to me. I can only assume that it was in modesty that you didn’t mention that you also work from home and contribute to your family’s income as did Mom for many years.
This issue has been debated for a long time and remarks like those that got you riled up usually come from those ignorant of the facts.
Thanks Dad! You and Mom provided such nearly-perfect examples of a wonderful home life, it was easy to simply mimic it! :-) Love you!
It’s funny how many news media outlets are just dripping with slime. Then I read this little gem on myjoyfortoday.wordpress.com and I think, wow. This is probably the best piece of journalism I have ever seen. Whoever you are, thank you. I wish everyone in the U.S. could read this.
Whoever YOU are- thank you! I really appreciate your kind words. Hope you keep reading!
Thanks for commenting on my post! I’m glad people did take notice of NPR’s slip-up, thanks to blogs and comments like yours. As a fellow educated (former) stay at home mom, I take exception to the idea that SAHM’s and educated women are mutually-exclusive categories. I can’t wait to read more of your posts!
Thanks so much! I really appreciate your comment and am so glad you stopped by.
Really great post.
I have so many things to say about this matter, but my words are so sloppy and just coming out wrong, so let me just say that I choose my choice and I respect and fight for the choice of all other women. And I just wish more women would do the same.
Wonderful writing!
I know! It took me all day to construct my thoughts in a concise manner. I really do not concern myself with the choices of others, but just wish others would not make assumptions about me based on my choices! Thanks for the comment!
CNN should hire you now! Actually NPR should hire you… and fire that lady who said those needed-to-be sensored remarks. We should make a petition to get you hired somewhere.
Thanks so much! If you start that petition, you will have at least 2 signatures- yours and mine! ;-)
I heard the slip up in the morning, too! I can’t believe it’s gone. Did you listen to the apologies the bnext morning? I wonder if they corrected it.
And though I don’t think I’ll be a stay at home mom, it doesn’t matter. I was enraged for women because whether we are educated or not, and whether we work at an office (or otherwise) or stay at home, it’s all our choice. We aren’t less because of it.
I didn’t listen the next day, so I wonder if they said anything. I wish they would put something on the website! I am soooo glad that you heard it! It seems we are a select bunch that actually did. And I agree- to each their own in terms of mothering/schooling/working choices, but at least we could all agree that we each came to those decisions carefully and respect the process.
What Ms. Liasson was reffering to when she said, “His [Mitt Romney’s] problem isn’t with stay at home moms, it’s with educated women.” was that Romney is behind Obama in the polls 20 points with stay at home moms and 30 points with college educated women.
If you make the assumption that those two groups are completely separate then it is a very offensive statement. However, as polling groups they of course overlap each other. So, what Ms. Liasson was saying is that Romney should focus on college educated women as a group because he is farther behind in the polls with them, which of course includes many stay-at-home moms.
My wife, who is also a stay-at-home mom, initially had the same reaction as you have expressed. :)
Yes, that is certainly what Ms. Liasson was referring to, and I am familiar with those polling numbers. It is true that stay at home moms with an education are a smaller percentage of the overall group of stay at home mothers, but we exist nonetheless. It was obviously just an error in her phrasing, but I think reveals some deeply held, underlying beliefs about stay at home moms in general. Also, we all tend to want to put each other, and women especially, into a box, and polling numbers exasperate that even more. Thank you for the comment and hope you keep reading!
I think that you perpetuated the war between SAHM and working moms by your angry response. You acknowledged that it was poor phrasing on Liasson’s part, but your anger is based on your subjective conclusion that it reveals some deeply held underlying belief. I don’t believe it does. You also acknowledged that the statement does reflect the general state of the demographic. As a fellow educated SAHM, I say relax, find the common ground and work to feel less isolated rather than more isolated.
I think we will have to agree to disagree because I do sincerely believe that comments like those reveal a bias. I certainly do not intend to perpetuate any “war” between stay at home and working mothers. I feel the battle I am waging is more between women and the media. The media tends to put women into categories, and then make assumptions about their choices, in a way that is not commonly seen towards men. Society as a whole does not know how to handle multifaceted, opinionated women. I appreciate you taking the time to comment.
[…] blog My Joy for Today reported her outrage on that day. She could not believe NPR was hiding its […]
[…] blog My Joy for Today reported her outrage on that day. She could not believe NPR was hiding its […]
[…] re-recorded our interview for later feeds, and that is the interview of record at NPR.org. The blog My Joy for Today reported her outrage on that day. She could not believe NPR was hiding its arrogance: I attempted […]
[…] blog was quoted in several news outlets, and a paragraph from my original post (https://myjoyfortoday.wordpress.com/2012/04/15/educated-stay-at-home-moms-an-oxymoron/) was used in many articles. Some of them can be found […]